Reference health

Authoritarian Legal (Ir)rationality:The Saga of 'Picking Quarrels' in China

https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4647656
CiteStamped reference-health badge
1/1 checkable references clean · checked 2026-08-02

Every reference with a DOI in the deposited reference list resolved to a known work in Crossref or DataCite at the dated check, and none carried a retraction, withdrawal, or removal notice.

153 without a DOI — not checked. A reference deposited without a DOI is never matched by title or guessed at; it stays outside the checked set, and this line discloses that.

The 1 checked reference that resolves
resolves10.1017/S0003055413000014
How Censorship in China Allows Government Criticism but Silences Collective Expression
The 153 references without a DOI — listed, not checked
no DOI — not checkedref1
no DOI — not checkedref2
no DOI — not checkedFly High the Banner of Socialist Rule of Law with Chinese Characteristics! What Does the 4th Plenum Decision Mean for Legal Reforms in China?
no DOI — not checkedOrder and Law in China, 2 UNIV. ILL
no DOI — not checkedChina's Dual State Revival Under Xi Jinping, 46 FORDHAM INT
no DOI — not checkedThe Concept of Authoritarian Legality: The Chinese Case
no DOI — not checkedref7
no DOI — not checkedref8
no DOI — not checkedref9
no DOI — not checkedChina's Long March Towards Rule of Law or China's Turn against Law?
no DOI — not checkedref11
no DOI — not checkedLaw in the China Model 2.0: Legality, Developmentalism and Leninism under Xi Jinping, 26 J. OF CONTEMP
no DOI — not checkedref13
no DOI — not checkedDepoliticized Responses: Political Monitoring in China's Transition in SURVEILLANCE, COUNTER-TERRORISM AND COMP
no DOI — not checkedIntroduction: Authoritarian Legality, the Rule of Law, and Democracy
no DOI — not checkedref16
no DOI — not checkedref17
no DOI — not checkedref18
no DOI — not checkedref19
no DOI — not checkedChina's Changing of the Guard: Authoritarian Resilience
no DOI — not checkedExploring for Constitutionalism in 21 st Century China
no DOI — not checkedref22
no DOI — not checkedref23
no DOI — not checkedref24
no DOI — not checkedSee also Wang Yaohua(? ??), Qianxi yi Lian'ai Weiming Jianwu Fun� de Liumangzui (?????????? ?????) [A Brief Analysis of the Hooligan Crime of Raping Women in the Name of Romantic Relationship] 3 FAXUE PINGLUN(????)
no DOI — not checkedref26
no DOI — not checkedLiumangzui Rending Qianxi (???? ???) [A Brief Analysis on the Determination of Hooliganism], 1 FAXUE PINGLUN (? ???) [LAW REVIEW
no DOI — not checkedDialogue-Issue 30: Release of Last Known June Fourth Spy
no DOI — not checked139 See Humin Deng Liumagzui Yishen Panjueshu (???????????) [Criminal First Instance Verdict of Humin and Others Hooliganism] Xingyichuzi No.25 (Yueyang Interm
no DOI — not checkedTHE DEVELOPMENT OF CHINA'S CRIMINAL LAW IN THE 40 YEARS OF REFORM AND OPENING]
no DOI — not checkedThe Crime of Hooliganism should be Divided into Two Kinds of Crimes--Also on the Establishment of the Crime of Womanizing], 46 GUANGXI DAXUE XUEBAO ZHEXUE SHEHUI KEXUE BAN (??????(???????))
no DOI — not checkedref32
no DOI — not checkedThe Crime of Hooliganism should be Divided] 5 XIANDAI FAXUE (????)
no DOI — not checkedref34
no DOI — not checkedref35
no DOI — not checkedSee Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (promulgated by Standing Comm
no DOI — not checkedCollective Petition and Local State Responses in Rural China
no DOI — not checkedOn the Petition System in China 12 U. ST
no DOI — not checkedref39
no DOI — not checkedref40
no DOI — not checkedThe Communist Party Leadership and Rule of Law: A Tale of Two Reforms, 30 J. OF CONTEMP
no DOI — not checkedA Law Unto Itself: Chinese Communist Party Leadership and Yifa zhiguo in the Xi Era, 44 MOD
no DOI — not checkedref43
no DOI — not checkedFrom Independent Lawyer Groups to Civic Opposition: The Case of China's New Citizen Movement, 19 ASIAN-PAC
no DOI — not checkedref45
no DOI — not checkedThe July 9th (709) Crackdown on Human Rights Lawyers: Legal Advocacy in an Authoritarian State
no DOI — not checked170 See infra discussion in this section, especially section A,B and C. 171 Nesossi et al., supra note 102, at 6, 17; see Wang & Minzner, supra note 102 (explaining why and how that happened); THE POLITICS OF LAW AND STABILITY IN CHINA 21-79
no DOI — not checkedFalun Gong Problem": Politics and the Struggle for the Rule of Law in China
no DOI — not checkedref49
no DOI — not checkedFeizhengchang Shangfang Xingwei Xingfa Guizhi de Fansi yu Xiansuo: yi 2018-2019 nianjian de 320 fen Caipan Wenshu wei Yangben (???????????????? ?) [Reflection and Restriction of Criminal Law Regulation on Abnormal Letter and Visiting-Taking 320 Judgment Documents from 2018 to 2019 as Samples], 6 Neimenggu Shifan Daxue Xuebao (Zhexue Shehui Kexue ban) (?????????) (????? ??)
no DOI — not checkedSee Du Moumou fan Xunxinzishizui Er'shen Xingshi Panjueshu (????? ???????????) [Second Instance Criminal Verdict of Du Moumou Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble]
no DOI — not checkedref52
no DOI — not checkedSocial Governance Through Judiciary: The End of Letters and Visits and Picking Quarrels and Provoking Troubles
no DOI — not checkedFirst Instance Criminal Verdict of Dai Tingyi and Yin Huari Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble
no DOI — not checkedref55
no DOI — not checkedref56
no DOI — not checkedReverse-Engineering Censorship in China: Randomized Experimentation and Participant Observation
no DOI — not checkedref59
no DOI — not checkedBoundaries of Tolerance: Chapter 08 and Debates over Political Reform
no DOI — not checkedref61
no DOI — not checkedZhang Wenfang Xunxinzishizui Yishen Xingshi Panjueshu (???????????????) [First Instance Criminal Verdict of Zhang Wenfang Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble], Ji1 082 Xingchu (Sanhe Interm. People's Ct
no DOI — not checkedref63
no DOI — not checkedref64
no DOI — not checkedFirst Instance Criminal Verdict of Liu Hongbo Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble
no DOI — not checkedInterpretation of the Several Issues concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Handling of Defamation through Internet and Other Criminal Cases, Judicial Interpretation] (promulgated by the Judicial Comm
no DOI — not checkedKoudai' Shuxing de Xianzhi he Xiaomie (??????'??'????????) [On the Restriction and Reduction of the "Catchall" Nature of the Crime of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble"], 3 Zheng Fa Lun Cong (????)
no DOI — not checkedref68
no DOI — not checkedref69
no DOI — not checkedref70
no DOI — not checkedref71
no DOI — not checkedref72
no DOI — not checkedChina Since Tiananmen: Online Activism
no DOI — not checkedXi Jinping: Dang de Xinwen Yulun Gongzuo Bixu Tingqi Jingshen Jiliang (????????????????????) [Xi Jinping: The Party's News and Public Opinion Work Must Straighten Its Spiritual Backbone], RENMINWANG (???)
no DOI — not checkedref75
no DOI — not checkedChina Cracks Down on Social Media with Threat of Jail for 'Online Rumours
no DOI — not checkedref77
no DOI — not checkedref78
no DOI — not checked217 While comprehensive studies of these campaigns are urgently needed, it's widely reported by media that China has frequently initiated Internet "purification" campaigns under Xi's leadership
no DOI — not checked14, 15 and 16 of the Criminal Code of the People's Republic of China
no DOI — not checkedThe 2012 Revision of the Chinese Criminal Procedure Law: (Mostly) Old Wine in New Bottles
no DOI — not checkedSecond Instance Criminal Verdict of Yang Desong Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble], Gan 07 Xingzhong (Ganzhou Interm. People's Ct
no DOI — not checkedref83
no DOI — not checkedref84
no DOI — not checkedFirst Instance Criminal Verdict of Shang Qiuzhi Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble and Fraud], Yu 0381 Xingchu (Yanshi Interm. People's Ct
no DOI — not checkedSecond Instance Criminal Verdict of Yan Chunfeng Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble
no DOI — not checkedref87
no DOI — not checkedref88
no DOI — not checkedref89
no DOI — not checkedref90
no DOI — not checkedref91
no DOI — not checkedXiaokan Huanyu (????), Sun Dawu An Qisushu, Jiuzong Zui de Shishi he Xijie (?????????????????) [The indictment of the Sun Dawu case, facts, and details of the nine charges
no DOI — not checkedref93
no DOI — not checkedSee Ying Ni, Zhongguo Xinwen Zhoukan 'Yingxiang Zhongguo 2013 Niandu Renwu' Jiexiao (??????"???? 2013 ????"??) [China News Weekly's "People Influencing China in 2013
no DOI — not checked264 Pu Zhiqiang An Yishen Bianhuci, (?????????) [Defense Statement of Pu Zhiqiang Trial's First Instance], (????????)
no DOI — not checkedWo he zhe laoyezi, Meisha Keshuo de: dao Zhangsizhi (????????????????-????) [This Old Man and I Need not Say Anything to Understand Each Other -Mourning for Zhang Sizhi]
no DOI — not checked35 of the Constitution of the People's Republic of China guarantees the freedom of speech, assembly, association, procession, and demonstration
no DOI — not checkedYifa Shenpan Puzhiqiang An, Faguan ke Wushi Qita (????????????????) [Judging the Pu Zhiqiang Case According to law, Judges Can Ignore Other Things
no DOI — not checkedref99
no DOI — not checkedref100
no DOI — not checkedref101
no DOI — not checkedKoudaizui' Xunxinzishizui Weihe Rang Meigeren dou Mianlin Weixian, (???'???'????????????????), [China: Why the 'Catchall Crime' of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble Puts Everyone at Risk], Guoji teshe zuzh? (??????) [AMNESTY INT'L]
no DOI — not checked280 2012 nian Quanguo Fayuan Sifa Tongji Gongbao (2012 ???????? ???)
no DOI — not checkedZuigao Renmin Fayuan Gongzuo Baogao: 2021nian 3yue 8ri zai di Shisanjie Quanguo Renmin Daibiao Dahui Disici Huiyi Shang (???? ???????2021 ? 3 ? 8 ????????????????????)
no DOI — not checkedMass Digitization of Chinese Court Decisions: How to Use Text as Data in the Field of Chinese Law
no DOI — not checkedTongji Shuju de Gongkai: Xianzhuang yu Jianyi (?????????????????) [Disclosure of Judicial Statistics in China: Current Situation and Policy Suggestions], 2 ZHONGGUO YINGYONG FAXUE (??????)
no DOI — not checkedref107
no DOI — not checkedref108
no DOI — not checkedXunxinzishizui Panjue zi 2013qi Ranbaoshi Zengzhang Yi Chaoguo 32wan Jian, Zhejiang Henan Shanghai Xunxinzishi Panjue Shuliang Quanguo Lingxian (???????? 2013 ?????????? 32 ? ????????????????????) [The number of Picking Quarrels Verdicts has exploded to more than 320,000 since 2013, and the Number of Picking Quarrels Verdicts in Zhejiang, Henan, and Shanghai Leads the Country] DUANDIANXING (???) TERMINUS 2049
no DOI — not checkedref110
no DOI — not checkedZuigaojian 'Anguanban Fuzeren jiu 2022nian 1zhi6yue Quanguo Jiancha jiguan Zhuyao Ban'an Shuju Dajizhewen" (???'??????'? 2022 ? 1 ? 6 ????????????? ????) [The head of the Supreme Prosecutorial Office Answered News Reporters' questions on Main Case-handling Data of the Nationwide Procuratorate organs from January to
no DOI — not checkedInterpretation of the Several Issues concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Handling of Defamation through Internet and Other Criminal Cases, Judicial Interpretation] Sup
no DOI — not checkedOpinions on punishing medical crimes in accordance with the law and maintaining normal medical order, Judicial Issue] (promulgated by the Sup. People's Ct
no DOI — not checkedref114
no DOI — not checkedref115
no DOI — not checkedref116
no DOI — not checkedref117
no DOI — not checkedref118
no DOI — not checkedGuiding Opinions on Punishing Illegal and Criminal Acts that Obstruct Safe Driving on Public Transportation According to the Law, Ministry of Public Security and Ministry of Transportation Joint Release] (promulgated by the Sup. People's Ct
no DOI — not checkedOpinions on Several Issues Related to Handling Cases of Crimes by Malign Forces] (promulgated by the Sup. People's Ct
no DOI — not checkedTaoludai" Xingshi Anjian Ruogan Wenti de Yijian, fafa [2019] Shiyihao (????"???
no DOI — not checkedOpinions regarding Several Issues on Handling Criminal Cases involving
no DOI — not checkedIn addition, the 2020 revision of the Criminal Code of the PRC added Article 293 (1) alongside the original Picking Quarrels article, expanding the catch-all crime to include those who "conduct usury or collect other illegal debts" using violence and other coercive methods
no DOI — not checkedSee Zuigao Renmin Fayuan Zuigao Renmin Jianchayuan Gong'anbu Sifabu Yinfa Guanyu Yifa Chengzhi Fanghai Xinxing Guanzhuang Bingdu Ganran Feiyan Yiqing Fangkong Weifa Fanzui de Yijian, fafa [2020] Qihao (??????????? ????????????? ?????????????????????? Commented [MH157]: Dear Mr. Luo, Please consider adding a citation here. It may also help to further the reader's understanding
no DOI — not checkedSupreme People's Court, Supreme People's Procuratorate, Ministry of Public Security and Ministry of Justice Issued Notice on 'Opinions on Punishing Crimes Obstructing the Prevention and Control of the Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia Epidemic Situation according to the Law
no DOI — not checkedKill the chicken to scare the monkey': Heavy penalties, excessive COVID-19 control mechanisms, and legal consciousness in China
no DOI — not checkedHualing Fu, Pandemic Control in China's Gated Communities
no DOI — not checkedWuhan Whistleblower' Remembered One Year on
no DOI — not checkedDeputy Chief Prosecutor Sun Qian of the Supreme People's Procuratorate talks about the application of law in criminal cases involving the epidemic] NANCHANGXIAN RENMIN ZHENGFU (???????) The Nanchang County People's Government
no DOI — not checkedDirector of the Legal Policy Research Office of the SPP, Jointly Answered Questions from MEDIA Reporters]
no DOI — not checkedref131
no DOI — not checkedref132
no DOI — not checkedref133
no DOI — not checkedLaw-Morality Ideology in the Xi Jinping Era
no DOI — not checkedref135
no DOI — not checkedWhy Do Judges Cite the Party? References to Party Ideology in Chinese Court Decisions, 18 CHINA: AN INT
no DOI — not checkedref137
no DOI — not checked????????????????? ?? 30 ??????) [The Ministry of Emergency Management and the Sichuan Provincial People's Government approved 30 comrades including Zhao Wankun as martyrs], XINHUAWANG (? ? ?) XINHUA NET
no DOI — not checkedShaoshu Wangmin Wuru Liangshan Huozai Xisheng Yinglie, Gedi Gong'an Tongbao Juliu Shiyuren (??? ???????????????????????) [A Few Netizens Insulted the Liangshan Fire to Sacrifice the Heroes, Local Police Notified and Detained More Than Ten People], PENGPAI (??), THE PAPER
no DOI — not checked???????? ??????) [First Instance Criminal Verdict of Chang Renyao Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble
no DOI — not checkedref141
no DOI — not checkedZuixing Fading Yuanze de Xiandai Tiaozhan jiqi Yingdui (? ??????????????) [The Contemporary Challenges and Countermeasures of the Principle of Nulla poena sine lege], 3 ZHENGFA LUNGCONG (? ???)
no DOI — not checkedRenquan Baozhang Shijiao xia Xunxingzishi Doudi Tiaokuan de Hexianxing Jiexi (?????????????? ???????) [Analysis on the Constitutionality of the Provisions of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Troubles from the Perspective of Human Rights Protection], 25 NANHAI FAXUE (????) S. CHINA SEA
no DOI — not checkedref144
no DOI — not checkedXunxin zishizui de jiangou Lixing yu Sifajingyan (?? ?????????????) [The Constructive Rationality and Judicial Experience of the Crime of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Troubles] 270:7 JINAN XUEBAO (ZHEXU SHEHUIKEEXUE BAN) (???????????) JINAN J. PHIL
no DOI — not checkedXingfa Xiuzheng'an (Shiyi) dui Koudaizui de Xiansuo Jiqi Yiyi (<?????(??)>???????????) [Criminal Law Amendment (Eleventh)'s Restrictions on Catchll Crimes and Their Significances], 4 DANGDAI FAXUE (????)
no DOI — not checkedref147
no DOI — not checkedref148
no DOI — not checkedShandong Yi Cunzhuren Huo Guopei (????????? 730 ????????? ???????) [After being Detained for 730 Day the Crime of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble without Prosecution, A Director of Village Committee in Shandong was Awarded State Compensation], PENGPAI (??) THE PAPER
no DOI — not checked?(??)1 (1)
no DOI — not checkedref151
no DOI — not checkedref152
no DOI — not checkedref153
no DOI — not checkedAdYLnw. 352 'Overreach' is a notable concept put forward by Susan Shirk explaining how the declining rationality of CCP leadership makes China's foreign and domestic policies more autocratic
What this badge says. CiteStamped means the CHECKABLE references of this work were clean at the dated check: each resolved to a known work in a public registry, and none carried a retraction notice at that time. It says nothing about the quality, findings, or importance of the work itself, and nothing about references deposited without a DOI.

checked 2026-08-02 — re-checked daily as this page is visited; titles and statuses come from Crossref and DataCite and are not part of the signed record

view as graph · paper page

Embed this badge

Both snippets point at the live badge image and link back to this page. The badge re-renders from the daily check, so an embed never goes stale by more than a day of visits.

<a href="https://citestamp.com/citestamped/10.2139/ssrn.4647656"><img src="https://citestamp.com/citestamped/10.2139/ssrn.4647656/badge.svg" alt="CiteStamped reference-health badge" width="460" height="64"></a>
[![CiteStamped reference-health badge](https://citestamp.com/citestamped/10.2139/ssrn.4647656/badge.svg)](https://citestamp.com/citestamped/10.2139/ssrn.4647656)